Peer-reviewed article
When a Child Needs a Transplant but Lacks Familial Social Support.
We present the case of a 19-month-old boy with complex congenital heart disease. His single father is skeptical of traditional medicine and does not offer the social support needed to make heart transplantation successful for his son.…
We present the case of a 19-month-old boy with complex congenital heart disease. His single father is skeptical of traditional medicine and does not offer the social support needed to make heart transplantation successful for his son. After the father demonstrates commitment to transplant success and provides enhanced social support, doctors place the child on a Berlin Heart (a biventricular assist device) as a bridge to transplantation and list him for transplant. When the child is matched to a donor heart, the father refuses transplantation, despite that it is the child's only chance for survival. His doctors report the case to child protective services, but they decline to take protective custody. The father then changes his mind and asks that the child be put back on the waiting list for transplant. By this time, the social supports the father implemented are no longer in place. This case raises a number of issues. First, should courts order heart transplantation when doctors believe that it is in the child's best interest and parents do not consent? Second, once parents refuse a transplant, can they change their minds? Third, if there are uncertainties regarding whether the child has the social support to make transplantation successful, should the child be relisted? Finally, should a child who is not currently a transplant candidate but who may become one in the future be supported with ventricular assist devices?
Related writing.
When families disagree with experts
I wrote last week about the deliberations at an FDA Advisory Committee meeting about an innovative gene therapy treatment for Duchenne Muscular Dystrophy. I highlighted the disconnect between the comments made by parents and patients, who
This is not a three-parent child
A strange paper recently appeared in Nature, reporting that some (“fewer than five”) babies had been born in the UK following a procedure known as mitochondrial replacement therapy (MRT.) The report was strange because it was not coming f
Money, miracles, and mortality in SMA
The child in the picture has spinal muscular atrophy (SMA). She made the news in Mumbai when her parents tried to one of the new and extraordinarily expensive treatments for her. This week's news was about two children who died from liver
Brain death and xenotransplantation research
OK, so researchers have genetically modified pigs and then transplanted their hearts into brain dead human bodies. Yesterday’s dystopian science fiction has become today’s human interest story. One of the most shocking things about these
About the author
John D. Lantos is a pediatrician and bioethicist writing on AI in medicine, neonatal intensive care, and end-of-life decisions. His essays appear in JAMA, JAMA Pediatrics, the Hastings Center Report, the New England Journal of Medicine, and Aeon. Read more about John.